Within Banner Plane
How a strange object became a banner plane
The case turned on corrected distance estimates, airport calls and a small tow plane that was easy to miss from Block Island.
On this page
- What Chip Taylor first reported from Block Island
- How distance and shoreline checks changed the case
- Why the Block Island Airport lead mattered
Page outline Jump by section
Introduction
A daylight sighting off Block Island in September 2012 began as a seemingly strong UFO report and ended as one of Rhode Island’s clearest examples of a local mystery being solved through careful checking rather than speculation. The witness, Chip Taylor, watched a distant object through binoculars for several minutes and initially saw what looked like a large, wingless, shape-changing craft moving along the shoreline. What changed the case was not a dramatic new photograph or government disclosure. It was a series of practical corrections: better estimates of distance, a closer look at the geography, and conversations with local airports. By the end of the investigation, the most convincing explanation was a large advertising banner being towed by a small aircraft that was difficult to see from Block Island. [Skeptical Inquirer]skepticalinquirer.orginvestigating the rhode island ufoAn advertisement banner in tow behind an airplane. “What you saw was most likely a large advertising banner…Read more…
The case remains useful within Rhode Island UFO history because it shows how a sincere observer can gather real details, make reasonable assumptions, and still be misled by scale, distance and viewing angle. Rather than exposing a hoax or proving an extraordinary event, the investigation demonstrated how an apparently puzzling object could become understandable once the local aviation context was reconstructed. [Skeptical Inquirer]skepticalinquirer.orginvestigating the rhode island ufoAn advertisement banner in tow behind an airplane. “What you saw was most likely a large advertising banner…Read more…
What Chip Taylor first reported from Block Island
Taylor’s observation did not fit the stereotype of a fleeting light in the night sky. He was on Block Island during a ham-radio event and was already paying close attention to the surrounding airspace and coastline. Through binoculars, he watched an object moving roughly parallel to the distant mainland shoreline. It appeared as a large parallelogram-shaped form with no visible wings, engine, propeller or towing aircraft. [Skeptical Inquirer]skepticalinquirer.orginvestigating the rhode island ufoAn advertisement banner in tow behind an airplane. “What you saw was most likely a large advertising banner…Read more…
Several features made the sighting seem unusual at first:
- The object appeared to change shape as it moved.
- It sometimes looked broader and more square, then longer and narrower.
- It travelled slowly enough to be observed for an extended period.
- The witness could not identify any conventional aircraft associated with it.
- It eventually disappeared behind low hills, creating the impression of a descent or dive. [Skeptical Inquirer]skepticalinquirer.orginvestigating the rhode island ufoAn advertisement banner in tow behind an airplane. “What you saw was most likely a large advertising banner…Read more…
Those details are important because they explain why the sighting initially resisted an easy explanation. The report was not built around a single ambiguous photograph. It included a prolonged visual observation and a witness trying to analyse what he was seeing in real time. That gave the case a degree of credibility while also creating opportunities for mistaken interpretation.
How distance and shoreline checks changed the case
The turning point came when Taylor revisited his assumptions about where the object actually was.
At first, he estimated the shoreline distance at roughly eight or nine miles. Later checks using maps and known viewing directions suggested that the object had been much farther away. The corrected estimate placed it around fourteen miles away when first observed and farther still when it vanished behind terrain. [Skeptical Inquirer]skepticalinquirer.orginvestigating the rhode island ufoAn advertisement banner in tow behind an airplane. “What you saw was most likely a large advertising banner…Read more…
That adjustment had major consequences.
A distant object viewed through binoculars can appear larger, stranger and more isolated than it really is. If the observer underestimates the distance by several miles, then estimates of the object’s size, speed and altitude can all become distorted. A conventional object may begin to seem extraordinary simply because the geometry is wrong.
The geography of the sighting also started to matter. Taylor checked where the object appeared to disappear and compared that line of sight with the mainland landscape. Instead of treating the disappearance as evidence of unusual manoeuvres, he examined whether local terrain could account for it. The question shifted from “What was that craft doing?” to “What exactly was I looking across?” [Skeptical Inquirer]skepticalinquirer.orginvestigating the rhode island ufoAn advertisement banner in tow behind an airplane. “What you saw was most likely a large advertising banner…Read more…
This was a crucial investigative change. Many UFO reports remain focused on the object itself. In this case, the investigation increasingly focused on the viewing conditions, shoreline positions and aviation activity in the area.
Why the Block Island Airport lead mattered
The first airport enquiries did not immediately solve the mystery.
Taylor contacted an airport in the direction where the object had appeared to vanish. Based on the description of a large, slow-moving, oddly shaped object, staff could not identify an obvious match. The possibility of military activity was even mentioned during the search for explanations. Those enquiries, however, produced no convincing aircraft that fit the report. [Skeptical Inquirer]skepticalinquirer.orginvestigating the rhode island ufoAn advertisement banner in tow behind an airplane. “What you saw was most likely a large advertising banner…Read more…
The breakthrough came only when he contacted Block Island Airport, much closer to his own observation point. According to Taylor’s later account, the airport manager immediately suggested a far more mundane possibility: a large advertising banner being towed along the shoreline by a small aircraft. [Skeptical Inquirer]skepticalinquirer.orginvestigating the rhode island ufoAn advertisement banner in tow behind an airplane. “What you saw was most likely a large advertising banner…Read more…
That suggestion succeeded because it addressed several puzzles at once.
A banner could explain the apparent rectangular or parallelogram shape. A towing aircraft could be present without being obvious from a long distance. The changing appearance could result from shifts in viewing angle as the banner twisted or altered its orientation relative to the observer. The final disappearance could be explained by terrain and perspective rather than a dramatic manoeuvre. [Skeptical Inquirer]skepticalinquirer.orginvestigating the rhode island ufoAn advertisement banner in tow behind an airplane. “What you saw was most likely a large advertising banner…Read more…
The explanation also fit local aviation practices. Follow-up enquiries found that banner-towing operations did work from the area around Westerly Airport. Taylor learned that such aircraft can tow very large banners, that the towing plane may be surprisingly difficult to see at a distance, and that banner movement can create the impression of changing shapes. [Skeptical Inquirer]skepticalinquirer.orginvestigating the rhode island ufoAn advertisement banner in tow behind an airplane. “What you saw was most likely a large advertising banner…Read more…
Why the tow plane was easy to miss
One reason the case initially looked impressive was that the witness never saw an obvious aircraft attached to the object.
In hindsight, that absence became part of the solution rather than part of the mystery.
Banner-towing aircraft are relatively small compared with the advertising material they pull. At significant distances, the banner may stand out visually while the aircraft remains difficult to detect. Depending on lighting conditions, haze, binocular focus and viewing angle, an observer’s attention can lock onto the larger object and effectively ignore the much smaller towing plane. [Skeptical Inquirer]skepticalinquirer.orginvestigating the rhode island ufoAn advertisement banner in tow behind an airplane. “What you saw was most likely a large advertising banner…Read more…
The arrangement can also create misleading impressions of movement. If the aircraft changes heading slightly while towing a flexible banner, the banner may appear to stretch, shorten, tilt or rotate. To a distant observer, those changes can look like an object changing shape rather than a fabric structure responding to airflow. [Skeptical Inquirer]skepticalinquirer.orginvestigating the rhode island ufoAn advertisement banner in tow behind an airplane. “What you saw was most likely a large advertising banner…Read more…
That insight solved one of the strongest parts of the original report. The shape-shifting behaviour was no longer evidence against a conventional explanation. It became evidence supporting one.
What the case shows about solved UFO reports
The Block Island sighting is valuable because it was not dismissed with a casual explanation. The banner-plane solution emerged only after the witness investigated his own report, corrected distance estimates, checked local geography and followed aviation leads. [Skeptical Inquirer]skepticalinquirer.orginvestigating the rhode island ufoAn advertisement banner in tow behind an airplane. “What you saw was most likely a large advertising banner…Read more…
Several lessons stand out:
- Accurate distance estimates are often the weakest part of visual sightings.
- Coastlines, hills and horizon features can create false impressions of altitude and movement.
- Small aircraft can disappear visually while larger objects associated with them remain obvious.
- A witness can be honest, attentive and careful while still reaching an incorrect conclusion.
- Local aviation knowledge can sometimes solve cases that seem mysterious from a purely visual description. [Skeptical Inquirer]skepticalinquirer.orginvestigating the rhode island ufoAn advertisement banner in tow behind an airplane. “What you saw was most likely a large advertising banner…Read more…
Within Rhode Island’s UFO record, the 2012 Block Island case is therefore notable not because it remained unexplained, but because it did not. The investigation followed a path from uncertainty to a specific, locally grounded answer. That makes it one of the state’s better examples of how a seemingly strong UFO report can weaken as more contextual information becomes available, without requiring anyone to accuse the witness of fabrication or bad faith.
Amazon book picks
Further Reading
Books and field guides related to How a strange object became a banner plane. Use these as the next step if you want deeper reading beyond the article.
The Demon-Haunted World
Rating: 4.5/5 from 43 Google Books ratings
Focuses on evidence, testing and alternative explanations.
Why People Believe Weird Things
Rating: 4.0/5 from 7 Google Books ratings
Relevant to solved mysteries and sincere misinterpretation.
eBay marketplace picks
Marketplace Samples
Example marketplace items related to this page. Use the search link to explore similar finds on eBay.
Endnotes
-
Source: skepticalinquirer.org
Title: investigating the rhode island ufo
Link: https://skepticalinquirer.org/newsletter/investigating-the-rhode-island-ufo/Source snippet
An advertisement banner in tow behind an airplane. “What you saw was most likely a large advertising banner...Read more...
Additional References
-
Source: youtube.com
Link: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eJJCHOMajGoSource snippet
Alderney UFO sighting explained | Why it's one of the most incredible ever recorded | This Is Why...
-
Source: youtube.com
Link: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ovb2uMYstwYSource snippet
The SHOCKING Math Error Behind Viral UFO Videos | Mick West...
-
Source: youtube.com
Link: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wbSU7GBlb7Y -
Source: youtube.com
Title: My UFO Mistake
Link: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_YIS16GfzfQSource snippet
[Banner plane]({{ 'banner-plane/' | relative_url }}) in Orange Beach pulls ad for OnlyFans account; mayor and beachgoers furious...
-
Source: youtube.com
Title: The SHOCKING Math Error Behind Viral UFO Videos | Mick West
Link: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ypfbhfEXnBoSource snippet
My UFO Mistake...
Topic Tree